Steelers Xtreme Forum


 
Homekeep or cut ? Home10RegisterLog inContact
Become a member of the Steelers Xtreme community to join in on the discussions and get access to members-only forums. Registering is free and easy.

 

 keep or cut ?

Go down 
4 posters
AuthorMessage
Master_Of_Puppets

Master_Of_Puppets


Posts : 2373
Join date : 2011-04-08

keep or cut ? Empty
PostSubject: keep or cut ?   keep or cut ? EmptyFri Dec 03, 2021 4:11 pm

ok you are the GM. EVERYBODY is a free agent next year. who do you give contracts to. you can copy and paste the list. I HAVE 24 KEEPERS.

52     Adams, Montravius DT
27     Allen, Marcus FS
29     Ballage, Kalen RB
72 Banner, Zach OT
9 Boswell, Chris PK

96 Buggs, Isaiah DT
55 Bush Jr., Devin IB
98 Charlton, Taco DE
11 Claypool, Chase WR
34 Edmunds, Terrell FS
67 Finney, BJ OC
39 Fitzpatrick, Minkah FS
88 Freiermuth, Pat TE
81 Gentry, Zach TE

54 Gilbert III, Ulysees IB
53 Green, Kendrick OC/OG
23 Haden, Joe CB
22 Harris, Najee RB
6 Harvin III, Pressley PT
3 Haskins, Dwayne QB

97 Heyward, Cameron DE
56 Highsmith, Alex.....OB

45 Johnson, Buddy IB
18 Johnson, Diontae WR

28 Killebrew, Miles SS
46 Kuntz, Christian OB
31 Layne, Justin CB
77 Leglue, John OT
92 Loudermilk, Isaiahh DT
35 Maulet, Arthur CB
14 McCloud, Ray-Ray WR
26 McFarland Jr., Anthony RB
17 Miller**, Anthony WR
99 Mondeaux, Henry DT
65 Moore Jr., Dan OT
21 Norwood, Tre FS

76 Okorafor, Chukwuma OT
42 Pierre, James CB
87 Rader, Kevin TE
7 Roethlisberger, Ben QB
2 Rudolph, Mason QB
93 Schobert, Joe IB/OB
24 Snell Jr., Benny RB
20 Sutton, Cameron CB
51 Turner, Trai OG

48 Tuszka, Derrek DE
13 Washington, James WR
44 Watt, Derek FB
15 White, Cody WR
25 Witherspoon, Ahkello CB
95 Wormley, Chris
30 Acy, DeMarkus CB
94 Alualu, Tyson DE
84 Bussey, Rico WR
93 Christmas, Demarcus DT
73 Davis, Carlos DT
5 Dobbs, Joshua QB
69 Dotson, Kevin OG
85 Ebron, Eric TE
71 Haeg, Joe OT
19 Smith-Schuster, JuJu WR
41 Spillane, Robert LB
91 Tuitt, Stephon DE
90 Watt, TJ OB
Back to top Go down
LambertWardSteel




Posts : 1456
Join date : 2015-05-14
Location : Myerstown PA

keep or cut ? Empty
PostSubject: Re: keep or cut ?   keep or cut ? EmptySat Dec 04, 2021 1:11 am

52     Adams, Montravius DT
27     Allen, Marcus FS
29     Ballage, Kalen RB
72 Banner, Zach OT
9 Boswell, Chris PK
96 Buggs, Isaiah DT
55 Bush Jr., Devin IB
98 Charlton, Taco DE
11 Claypool, Chase WR
34 Edmunds, Terrell FS
67 Finney, BJ OC
39 Fitzpatrick, Minkah FS
88 Freiermuth, Pat TE
81 Gentry, Zach TE
54 Gilbert III, Ulysees IB
53 Green, Kendrick OC/OG
23 Haden, Joe CB
22 Harris, Najee RB
6 Harvin III, Pressley PT
3 Haskins, Dwayne QB
97 Heyward, Cameron DE
56 Highsmith, Alex.....OB
45 Johnson, Buddy IB
18 Johnson, Diontae WR
28 Killebrew, Miles SS
46 Kuntz, Christian OB
31 Layne, Justin CB
77 Leglue, John OT
92 Loudermilk, Isaiahh DT
35 Maulet, Arthur CB
14 McCloud, Ray-Ray WR
26 McFarland Jr., Anthony RB
17 Miller**, Anthony WR
99 Mondeaux, Henry DT
65 Moore Jr., Dan OT
21 Norwood, Tre FS
76 Okorafor, Chukwuma OT
42 Pierre, James CB
87 Rader, Kevin TE
7 Roethlisberger, Ben QB
2 Rudolph, Mason QB
93 Schobert, Joe IB/OB
24 Snell Jr., Benny RB
20 Sutton, Cameron CB
51 Turner, Trai OG
48 Tuszka, Derrek DE
13 Washington, James WR
44 Watt, Derek FB
15 White, Cody WR
25 Witherspoon, Ahkello CB
95 Wormley, Chris
30 Acy, DeMarkus CB
94 Alualu, Tyson DE
84 Bussey, Rico WR
93 Christmas, Demarcus DT
73 Davis, Carlos DT
5 Dobbs, Joshua QB
69 Dotson, Kevin OG
85 Ebron, Eric TE
71 Haeg, Joe OT
19 Smith-Schuster, JuJu WR
41 Spillane, Robert LB
91 Tuitt, Stephon DE
90 Watt, TJ OB

_________________
keep or cut ? $_35
Back to top Go down
Master_Of_Puppets

Master_Of_Puppets


Posts : 2373
Join date : 2011-04-08

keep or cut ? Empty
PostSubject: Re: keep or cut ?   keep or cut ? EmptySat Dec 04, 2021 1:24 pm

good lawd ...your cutting all of the secondary but old ass joe haden ? keep or cut ? 1797695198
with the exception of this last game, pierre has played well.

your also cutting rookies ? if your cutting rookies based on a bad rookie year, then i guess you would have cut troy polomalu. Shocked
Back to top Go down
Great Randino




Posts : 1358
Join date : 2018-08-31

keep or cut ? Empty
PostSubject: Re: keep or cut ?   keep or cut ? EmptyMon Dec 06, 2021 1:56 am

These lists are why I'm forever grateful the Steelers don't let fans make roster decisions.
Back to top Go down
Master_Of_Puppets

Master_Of_Puppets


Posts : 2373
Join date : 2011-04-08

keep or cut ? Empty
PostSubject: Re: keep or cut ?   keep or cut ? EmptyMon Dec 06, 2021 3:09 am

@Great Randino wrote:
These lists are why I'm forever grateful the Steelers don't let fans make roster decisions.
so who you keeping ?
Back to top Go down
Stella Nation

Stella Nation


Posts : 1287
Join date : 2015-05-13
Location : Stella City

keep or cut ? Empty
PostSubject: Re: keep or cut ?   keep or cut ? EmptyWed Dec 08, 2021 5:27 am

52 Adams, Montravius DT
27 Allen, Marcus FS
29 Ballage, Kalen RB
72 Banner, Zach OT
9 Boswell, Chris K
96 Buggs, Isaiah DT
55 Bush Jr., Devin IB
98 Charlton, Taco DE
11 Claypool, Chase WR
34 Edmunds, Terrell SS
67 Finney, BJ OC
39 Fitzpatrick, Minkah FS
88 Freiermuth, Pat
81 Gentry, Zach TE
54 Gilbert III, Ulysees IB
53 Green, Kendrick OC/OG
23 Haden, Joe CB
22 Harris, Najee RB
6 Harvin III, Pressley P
3 Haskins, Dwayne QB
97 Heyward, Cameron DE
56 Highsmith, Alex.....OB
45 Johnson, Buddy IB
18 Johnson, Diontae WR

28 Killebrew, Miles SS
46 Kuntz, Christian LS
31 Layne, Justin CB
77 Leglue, John OG
92 Loudermilk, Isaiahh DT
35 Maulet, Arthur CB
14 McCloud, Ray-Ray WR
26 McFarland Jr., Anthony RB
17 Miller**, Anthony WR
99 Mondeaux, Henry DT
65 Moore Jr., Dan OT
21 Norwood, Tre FS
76 Okorafor, Chukwuma OT

42 Pierre, James CB
87 Rader, Kevin TE

7 Roethlisberger, Ben QB
2 Rudolph, Mason QB
93 Schobert, Joe IB/OB
24 Snell Jr., Benny RB
20 Sutton, Cameron CB
51 Turner, Trai OG

48 Tuszka, Derrek DE
13 Washington, James WR
44 Watt, Derek FB
15 White, Cody WR
25 Witherspoon, Ahkello CB
95 Wormley, Chris

30 Acy, DeMarkus CB
94 Alualu, Tyson DE
84 Bussey, Rico WR
93 Christmas, Demarcus DT
73 Davis, Carlos DT
5 Dobbs, Joshua QB
69 Dotson, Kevin OG
85 Ebron, Eric TE
71 Haeg, Joe OT
19 Smith-Schuster, JuJu WR
41 Spillane, Robert LB

91 Tuitt, Stephon DE
90 Watt, TJ OB
Back to top Go down
Stella Nation

Stella Nation


Posts : 1287
Join date : 2015-05-13
Location : Stella City

keep or cut ? Empty
PostSubject: Re: keep or cut ?   keep or cut ? EmptyWed Dec 08, 2021 6:00 am

I don't have them as keepers, but some of Marcus Allen, Gilbert III, Killebrew, Layne and Snell will make the final roster. That will depend on which positions we will find far superior better players. Together with Derek Watt they are our core special teamers and they are all excellent in that regard. We probably only can replace two of them in one season or our special teams will fall to shambles.

I have kept Banner, Okorafor and Haeg but only one (or two if we really can't find anyone better) of them will make the final roster. They can battle it out in training camp. I have kept Edmunds (cheap) for depth, not as a starter but if Killebrew makes the team as a ST, he's out. Rader and Davis get one more shot in training camp, they are on the bubble. Rader probably makes it, Davis probably won't.
Back to top Go down
Master_Of_Puppets

Master_Of_Puppets


Posts : 2373
Join date : 2011-04-08

keep or cut ? Empty
PostSubject: Re: keep or cut ?   keep or cut ? EmptyWed Dec 08, 2021 1:54 pm

there are 512 players on NFL practice squads right now (16 x 32 ). thats a lot of players to disregard and think none of them are better than what you have right now.  montravavious adams was just sitting on A PS dying for an opportunity. there is zero doubt in my mind he is better than both buggs and davis. noway does buggs or davis make that shoestring tackle adams made against the ravens.
john leglue in his first NFL start and all be it a small sample size played as well or better than BJ finney , jc hasenhauer , or haeg at left guard.
serviceable players are there to be had, it just takes the  investment in time to find them.

my gripe with the steelers and i have beaten this horse to death on this forum, is they are too complacent and not proactive enough with the roster. they sit on players until they prove in game time situations that they have no business be in the NFL. i find it hard to believe these guys look great in practice.
i validated my opinions on a bunch of players the steelers kept on their roster for multiple years that i felt just flat out sucked. so i googled their names to find out if any team gave them a roster spot after the steelers cut them. the vast majority of them never made it on another roster and most the others lasted only a year on another roster before exiting the league.


Last edited by Master_Of_Puppets on Wed Dec 08, 2021 2:08 pm; edited 1 time in total
Back to top Go down
Master_Of_Puppets

Master_Of_Puppets


Posts : 2373
Join date : 2011-04-08

keep or cut ? Empty
PostSubject: Re: keep or cut ?   keep or cut ? EmptyWed Dec 08, 2021 2:42 pm

@Great Randino wrote:
@Master_Of_Puppets wrote:
@Great Randino wrote:
These lists are why I'm forever grateful the Steelers don't let fans make roster decisions.
so who you keeping ?
Like everyone on here, I don't have the depth of knowledge (including practice evaluation) to make such calls.

At least I know what I don't know.
you have eyes and watch the games right ? it doesnt take an expert to notice who is playing well or who is not. it doesnt take an expert to know when a player keeps dropping passes or missing tackles that player is not doing there job very well.
i acknowledge it is not all cut and dry because we fans dont always know the players assignments on a given a play. like the ravens 4th down attempt. who was supposed to pick up the TE ? Bush or fitzpatrick ? i believe it was fitzpatrick who got caught looking in the backfield instead of focusing on getting to the TE but i could be wrong.

anyway i can still look at an individuals effort and form my own opinion if its good or bad .
drop pass bad, catch pass good
miss tackle bad. make tackle good.
throw interception bad. throw touchdown good.  keep or cut ? 1645253483

if we are just going to defer to the "experts" then whats the point of having discussions about sports?
these forums are just to pass time and chat with like minded individuals and share opinions . we dont have to be cheerleaders 24/7. if the "experts" got it right 100% of the time every team would be a superbowl contender because there wouldnt be any bad teams. now wouldnt that be boring ?  keep or cut ? 2981382511
Back to top Go down
Sponsored content





keep or cut ? Empty
PostSubject: Re: keep or cut ?   keep or cut ? Empty

Back to top Go down
 
keep or cut ?
Back to top 
Page 1 of 1

Permissions in this forum:You cannot reply to topics in this forum
Steelers Xtreme Forum :: Football & Other Sports :: Steelers Talk-
Jump to: